Looking for a tangy, refreshing end to your seafood feast? Look no further than Captain D’s Key Lime Pie – a zesty classic with roots in the Florida Keys. Priced affordably at $4.99, this creamy, tart dessert has quickly become a customer favorite.
🥧 What Is Captain D’s Key Lime Pie?
Key Lime Pie is a sweet, creamy, citrus-flavored dessert made from key lime juice, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk in a graham cracker crust. Captain D’s version stays true to tradition with a bright, tangy flavor balanced by rich sweetness – the perfect treat after a seafood meal.
📋 Key Lime Pie Nutrition Information
Nutrient
Value per Serving
Calories
360 Calories
Total Fat
18g
Saturated Fat
9g
Trans Fat
0g
Cholesterol
90mg
Sodium
240mg
Total Carbs
44g
Dietary Fiber
1g
Sugars
30g
Protein
4g
⚠️ Allergen Information
Allergen
Present In
Eggs
Yes (custard filling)
Milk
Yes (condensed milk, cream)
Wheat/Gluten
Yes (graham cracker crust)
Soy
Possible in crust or stabilizers
Nuts
No
Always confirm with the store for allergy-specific preparation info.
🧾 Ingredients Breakdown
Key Lime Juice – Gives the pie its signature tartness
Sweetened Condensed Milk – Adds creaminess and sweetness
Egg Yolks – Traditional thickening agent for the filling
Graham Cracker Crust – Crunchy base with a hint of cinnamon and brown sugar
Whipped Cream Topping – Light and airy to contrast the pie’s richness
🍴 Why People Love Captain D’s Key Lime Pie
Bright, tart flavor that cuts through savory dishes
Rich, creamy texture with a crunchy crust
Conveniently portioned for dine-in or takeout
Perfect contrast to fried seafood and salty sides
Real key lime flavor, not artificial or overly sweet
Affordable indulgence that feels gourmet
📈 How It Compares to Other Fast Food Desserts
Restaurant
Dessert
Price
Calories
Description
Captain D’s
Key Lime Pie
$4.99
360
Tart and creamy, Florida-style classic
McDonald’s
Apple Pie
$1.89
240
Hot, flaky, cinnamon-spiced
KFC
Chocolate Chip Cake
$5.99
430
Dense and rich, best for chocolate fans
Popeyes
Banana Cream Pudding
$2.99
280
Sweet and soft, but less tart flavor
🍋 Expert Tips for Enjoying Key Lime Pie
Pair it with sweet tea for a Southern-style finish
Take it home and chill it for extra firmness
Eat the crust last to get the full buttery flavor
Ask for an extra whipped cream dollop if you love creamy textures
Save it for later—Key lime pie holds well in the fridge for up to 2 days
❓ FAQ – Captain D’s Key Lime Pie
1. Is this made with real key limes? Yes, it uses key lime juice, which has a more tart and floral flavor than regular limes.
2. Can I order this pie online? Yes, available through Captain D’s app and most food delivery services.
3. Is the crust homemade? It’s made in-store with a graham cracker-based crust.
4. Does it come frozen? It is served chilled, but not frozen solid.
5. Can I get it without whipped cream? Yes, just request it without when ordering.
6. Is it vegetarian? Yes. No meat or gelatin included.
7. Can I get a whole Key Lime Pie? Currently, only individual slices are sold.
8. Is it overly sweet? No. It’s well-balanced with tartness and light sweetness.
9. Is it gluten-free? No. The crust contains wheat.
10. Is the pie served warm or cold? Cold. It’s meant to be refreshing and cool.
11. Is there any coconut flavor? No. It’s a pure key lime flavor.
12. How does it compare to homemade? Surprisingly close in flavor and texture, especially for the price.
13. Can kids enjoy this? Absolutely! Many kids love the sweet-tart combo.
14. Does it pair well with seafood meals? Yes. It’s ideal after fried or grilled seafood.
15. Is it a seasonal item? No. It’s on the permanent dessert menu.
🏁 Final Verdict – Should You Try Captain D’s Key Lime Pie?
Yes, without hesitation. Whether you’re a dessert aficionado or just want to end your meal on a refreshing note, Captain D’s Key Lime Pie is a standout item. The tart citrus, creamy filling, and affordable price make it one of the best-value fast food desserts in 2025.
So next time you’re ordering that seafood platter, do yourself a favor and add this pie to your tray. It’s the Florida Keys in every bite, and it’s calling your name.
